Иллюстрация: Danny Berkovskii / Медиазона
Natalia Kozhemiatska, a tobacco kiosk manager from occupied Nova Kakhovka, agreed to cooperate with Ukrainian intelligence in the hope of saving her son from being sent to the front line. She was arrested by Russian security forces, endured torture and rape, missed the funeral of her mother—who was killed in a drone strike—and ultimately found herself charged with “aiding terrorism.”
Standing trial alongside Kozhemiatska were three other residents of her hometown: Kostiantyn Semeniuk, Anastasia Bernatska, and Pavlo Peleshuk. All four claim they spent six months being held in “basements,” where they were forced to memorize confessions dictated to them by “unpleasant men in masks.” The Southern District Military Court sentenced them to prison terms ranging from 13 to 14 years.
Mediazona reports on the trial of the four people from Nova Kakhovka—and the role of Judge Denis Vovchenko, who remained convinced that the torture used against the defendants was simply a means of “extracting the truth.”
In October 2025, 66-year-old Anna Bindiukova was returning with relatives to occupied Nova Kakhovka after attending her nephew’s funeral when a drone struck their vehicle. The impact hit the side where the pensioner was sitting, and she died instantly.
Neither of her two daughters was able to attend the funeral: Tetiana had evacuated to the Kyiv region with her children following the start of the full-scale war, while Natalia had been taken by Russian security forces more than a year earlier.
On 17 May 2024, as 45-year-old Natalia Kozhemiatska was on her way to work, to a tobacco kiosk, she was approached by a few men she didn’t know. Contact with her was lost for several hours, and that evening, the same men brought her back to her mother’s home.
“Natasha was terrified; she couldn’t even speak,” says her sister, Tetiana. “The only thing she told our mother was that they had tortured her with electric shocks and tried to force her to confess to something—she didn’t understand what exactly.”
According to Tetiana, her sister stayed home that evening, “believing that they wouldn't detain her again, since she hadn’t done anything wrong.” However, shortly before midnight, they came for Natalia once more.
“They told her: ‘Get ready, you’re coming with us for the long haul,’” Tetiana recalls.
Kozhemiatska was taken to the basement of the former police headquarters in Nova Kakhovka, and she spent the next six and a half months there and in other secret prisons of the area, her sister says. It was there that Natalia finally learned what she was being accused of. A week before her abduction, a car belonging to Maksim Karyi—a local police officer appointed by the occupation authorities as a chief specialist in the Nova Kakhovka security department—had been blown up in the city.
Natalia Kozhemiatska. Photo: Mediazona
Karyi remained unharmed: before getting into his Škoda Octavia, he inspected the vehicle, noticed an object “resembling a phone box” attached to the undercarriage, and called in bomb disposal experts. During the defusal attempt, the device detonated; FSB explosives expert Mikhail Sverdlikov sustained severe injuries and died that same day. The car was destroyed by fire.
On 10 May 2024, the division of the Investigative Committee for Nova Kakhovka opened a case involving attempted murder and an attack on the life of a law enforcement officer (ten months later, the charges were reclassified under a more serious provision: aiding and abetting terrorism).
Natalia Kozhemiatska, who was detained on May 17, became one of four individuals charged in the case.
Natalia Kozhemiatska with her mother. Photo: family archive / Mediazona
On the same day, FSB operatives detained her acquaintance, 27-year-old electronics store clerk Kostiantyn Semeniuk, and her neighbor, 31-year-old worker Pavel Peleshuk. The following day, May 18, Peleshuk’s partner, 25-year-old pharmacist Anastasia Bernatska, was detained as well.
However, the criminal case files list entirely different dates for their arrests. According to the investigation, Kozhemiatska was detained nearly six months later, on 5 November 2024, and her alleged accomplices on November 25. It was not until December 4 that the Genichesk District Court remanded Kozhemiatska in custody, followed by Bernatska, Peleshuk, and Semeniuk on December 24.
The investigation asserts that all the accused held “pro-Ukrainian views” and assisted in preparing the assassination of Karyi, with the intent to “foment distrust” toward the occupation authorities, portray them as helpless, and thereby persuade Russia to end the war.
The trial of four Nova Kakhovka residents started at the Southern District Military Court in April 2025. Presiding over the case was Denis Vovchenko, described in the only review on his profile on the “Judges of Russia” website as a “fair, concise, and responsible judge with a pleasant appearance.”
Vovchenko conducts hearings in a stern manner: he rushes the participants and is known to shout at both the defendants and their attorneys.
In her court testimony, Natalia Kozhemiatska stated that in March 2024, Bernatskaya introduced her to a man known as “Roy.” Kozhemiatska did not know his true identity, but “it was easy to guess that he worked for the Ukrainian intelligence services.”
Bernatskaya claimed that “Roy” was a “reliable person who could help” Natalia by ensuring: her then 21-year-old son—who has been serving in the Armed Forces of Ukraine since 2021—would not be sent to the front line.
Anastasia Bernatska. Photo: Mediazona
At first, Kozhemiatska was unable to reach “Roy,” but he then contacted her himself. She sent him information and a photograph of her son, and the man promised to help. In return, he asked her to find out the make and license plate number of Karyi’s car, as well as his exact address. Kozhemiatska did not know why he wanted this, but, by her own admission, “it was easy to guess that they intended to eliminate him.”
Although “everyone in Nova Kakhovka” knew what kind of car Karyi drove, she decided to double-check with an acquaintance, Semeniuk—without mentioning “Roy” to him.
Around the same time, in the spring of 2024, Bernatska forwarded a message to Kozhemiatska from “Roy,” who asked her—”if the opportunity arose”—to find out which office Karyi and several of his colleagues occupied within the civil-military administration building. Kozhemiatska went there, claiming she needed to find out what paperwork was required to lease a tobacco kiosk. However, she was unable to obtain the information “Roy” had requested: the officials directed her to a different office. So Kozhemiatska “did not send him any message.”
After that, “Roy” sent her another address and asked her to check whether Karyi parked his car there.
On 3 May 2024, Kozhemiatska visited the store where Semeniuk worked. “We talked; there was information that he might be visiting a young woman. I said that it was possible he showed up there,” she said in court. Semeniuk did not ask why Kozhemiatska was interested in Karyi, but she believes he “guessed.”
Kozhemyatskaya paid no attention to the explosion on 10 May 2024: “We have explosions every day.” It was only the next day, while heading to work early in the morning, that she saw a burnt-out car parked at the very address she had recently “checked.” At that point, “Roy” asked her to take photos of the aftermath of the explosion. Kozhemiatska did so. She had no objection to the photos being published “on a Telegram channel.”
Kozhemiatska admitted partial guilt, clarifying that she “did not want people to die” and “deeply regrets” the death of the explosives expert, Sverdlikov. The judge was not satisfied with this, stating that, in his own view, the defendant was effectively making a full confession.
“At the time, did you hold pro-Ukrainian views and oppose the ‘special military operation’? And why were you gathering information on staff members and military personnel?” Vovchenko pressed.
“Because of my son,” Kozhemiatska replied. “I didn’t plant the bomb myself. I only gathered information—I provided details like license plate numbers and the vehicles they drove. I never wanted anyone to die.”
When asked whether she understood that she was helping to orchestrate the murder of Karyi, the judge—his voice stern—reminded her that “there is only one truth.” After a long pause, Kozhemiatska answered, “Yes.”
When the defense attorney asked whether she had been subjected to “psychological pressure or physical force,” Vovchenko objected: “We know you were questioned during the preliminary investigation. At that time, you essentially admitted your guilt and described the same circumstances you are recounting now. It’s just that… well, if a person claims they are not guilty at all and asserts that all those statements made during the investigation were coerced…”
Ultimately, the court heeded the defense attorney, who argued that the testimony given during the investigation contained “points” that Kozhemyatskaya now “categorically” denied.
“I was subjected to electric shocks, struck on the head, and forced into sexual intercourse without my consent,” Kozhemiatska said during the hearing on June 10, choosing her words slowly and with great difficulty.
Natalia managed to whisper to her mother that she had been raped during their first meeting since her capture six and a half months earlier. In November 2024, FSB officers allowed them a brief encounter at a police station in the settlement of Novotroitske, in the Kherson region.
“They were given only a few minutes,” says Tetiana, Natalia’s sister. “As she hugged our mother goodbye, she whispered, ‘Mommy, I’ve been raped real bad.’ Mom told me later, ‘Tetiana, she was covered in black-and-blue bruises.’ It was clear that things were extremely difficult for Natalia there.”
Kozhemiatska testified in court that she was only permitted to see her mother after she had signed a confession.
She later retracted many of the claims made in that initial statement—specifically, that she had discussed “assignments” with Peleshuk, that Semeniuk was aware of “Roy,” and that “Roy” had offered 100,000 hryvnias in exchange for gathering information.
“I was genuinely very afraid for my mother, my father, and my husband. You see, around December 5th, after my first court hearing, an FSB officer came to see me, and they threatened me. This happened in Novotroitske,” she explained, accounting for the discrepancies in her testimony.
Investigator Shabanov did not threaten her personally; he simply handed her a pre-written statement to sign, Kozhemiatska recalled in court. Judge Vovchenko was not particularly moved by this.
“I have to wonder: is it even necessary to initiate a formal procedural inquiry into those individuals, given that you ultimately provided testimony in court that incriminates yourself?” he asked, sounding reluctant. “What kind of testimony did they ‘beat’ out of you? Turns out, it was the truth, wasn’t it?”
Kozhemiatska replied that while some of the testimony in the case file was true, “not all of it” was.
“If you had said, ‘Look, I wasn’t even anywhere near there. I was somewhere else entirely; they just grabbed me by the scruff of the neck. I don’t know Bernatska, I don’t know Semeniuk, I don’t know any of these people...’ And then a record appeared in which you pleaded guilty, well, that would be a different story. But in this hearing, you’ve given your account, and no one is pressuring you now, are they?” the judge continued. “Is an inquiry really necessary? I mean, who exactly would we even be looking for? There’s no specific individual here against whom such an inquiry could be directed.”
Ultimately, Kozhemyatskaya agreed that there were no grounds for an internal investigation.
“Did you report the use of violence against you or any other crimes to the authorities?” the judge asked.
“I was told not to report it. I spent nearly seven months in a basement—from May 17 to November 25, 2024,” Kozhemiatska replied quietly.
Pavlo Peleshuk was scheduled to be questioned at the next hearing.
“I trust that no actions were taken against you?” the judge asked him in advance.
“Actions were taken—physical violence—but I will not be requesting an internal investigation. Besides, I don’t even know who it was,” Peleshuk answered.
“Well, you were telling the truth, weren’t you? Do you think I don’t realize you were being held there? The question is to what extent this testimony might be untruthful. As you can see, your neighbor, Natalia Vasilyevna, claims that some sort of serious torture was used… But, all in all, she did provide a confession. The rest is just a matter of nuance,” the judge said, concluding the hearing.
According to his sister Yulia, Pavlo Peleshuk was working at a construction materials factory when the full-scale war began. His girlfriend, Anastasia Bernatska, was a pharmacist; in letters sent from captivity, she mentions that she completed her internship at Zaporizhzhia State Medical University in 2023.
The young couple had not planned to leave their hometown despite the occupation. “I tried to persuade them,” Yulia says. “At one point they even agreed, but then they changed their minds. I don’t know; perhaps they were afraid to leave. After all, that would mean abandoning everything you own and heading into the unknown with nothing.”
Pavlo Peleshuk. Photo: Mediazona
In 2023, as Peleshuk himself recalled in court, he subscribed to the Telegram channel PRO-Tavriisk, “to see the news, information about side jobs, and what was happening in the city.” One of the channel’s administrators went by the handle “Roy,” and Peleshuk would occasionally “ask him questions about side jobs.”
At one point, a post appeared in the channel asking for help locating where a Škoda Octavia with specific license plates was parked. Peleshuk, having seen the car in town, responded to the request.
The young man was detained on 17 May 2024. He was smoking on his balcony when someone began knocking on the door of the apartment he shared with Bernatska; Anastasiya opened it.
“And what happened next? Was there any interaction with you?” the prosecutor asked Peleshuk in court.
“They took me out into the stairwell. In the stairwell, they struck me in the face. I lost consciousness,” he replied.
For the next two or three days, security forces beat him at an undisclosed location, “asked questions,” and subjected him to electric shocks.
“I started making things up just to make it all stop,” Peleshuk continued. “To get them to stop hitting me with electric shocks and rubber batons. Later, they moved me to another place, where the torture continued. They kept asking about explosives.”
In court, Peleshuk insisted that he did not know anyone by the name of “Roy,” nor was he aware of any plot to blow up Karyi’s car in Nova Kakhovka. “The investigator told me what I should say,” he explained, referring to his initial testimony.
Yulia only learned of her brother’s and his girlfriend’s detention at the end of May. For six months, there was no contact with them; it was not until November—when a criminal case was officially opened—that it became clear the young couple was being held in a pre-trial detention center in Chongar. Their relatives began bringing them parcels and writing letters. Prior to that, Peleshuk and Bernatskaya had been “moved between various detention facilities in the Kherson region.”
Yulia says that before his arrest, Pavlo “had all his teeth.” But now, “two of his front teeth are missing.” According to her, while he was in a detention centre in Rostov-on-Don, his molars were also pulled out: “Maybe they didn’t want to provide dental care, or perhaps there was nothing left to treat.”
In court, Peleshuk spoke very quietly and inarticulately. This infuriated Judge Vovchenko, who demanded that the defense attorney conduct the questioning in a strict “question-and-answer” format. The attorney objected.
“Well, then, tell him to speak clearly!” Vovchenko snapped, mocking Peleshuk’s speech: “Th-th-th… bu-bu-bu…”
In court, Kostiantyn Semeniuk admitted that he had provided Kozhemiatska with the make, model, and license plate number of Karyi’s vehicle. However, he clarified that this information was subsequently used "to carry out a terrorist attack" without his knowledge.
According to Semeniuk, in March 2024, he stopped by a kiosk to buy cigarettes. The saleswoman—Kozhemiatska, whom he knew—mentioned that a military man had reached out to her, offering to “help resolve an issue regarding her son” by ensuring the young man would be stationed “far away from the front lines.” Semeniuk said he “didn't quite grasp” how this could be arranged, but he was happy for the woman.
Kostiantyn Semeniuk. Photo: Mediazona
A few days later, Kozhemiatska asked him to find out where Maksim Karyi lived and what kind of car he drove.
The former police officer frequently appeared in the news, so Semeniuk recognised him on sight; he had seen Karyi driving around the city and had even encountered him outside his own apartment building, where Karyi had been “asking about the residents.”
Semenyuk provided Kozhemiatska with the address where he had seen Kary, along with the make and license plate number of his car. When the prosecutor asked how he knew the license plate number, he attributed it to his “good memory” and easily recited the digits. He claimed that, at the time, he believed Natalia was looking for a way to reach the city administration to “sort out some paperwork” and secure a lease for a tobacco kiosk. Karyi had personally visited his electronics store, demanded to see documents, and remarked that “they’re collecting [information] from everyone right now.” So Semeniuk wasn’t surprised by Kozhemiatska’s request, he explained, especially since they had developed a “friendly relationship.”
On 3 May 2024, Kozhemiatska visited Semenyuk at his shop and asked about another address on Prospekt Pobedy (Victory Avenue). Semenyuk mentioned that Karyi visited a young woman named Tetiana there and showed Kozhemiatska a photograph of her. This conversation was partially captured by a surveillance camera. While Karyi’s surname is not mentioned in the recording, the two discuss the woman’s appearance in detail—commenting on her figure, her braid, her “little ass,” and her “little lips.”
According to Semeniuk, he only learned about the explosion the following day from an acquaintance who worked for the military-civil administration.
The prosecutor asked what Semeniuk’s attitude toward the “special military operation” had been in 2022.
“My hope was simply that it would end as quickly as it had begun—after all, it’s hardly pleasant to have things exploding over your head,” he replied. “I’m not a politician; I can’t really say... I don’t understand what the state’s position is... I’m just an ordinary, simple citizen who was working. I lived a very simple life: work, home, home, work. The store, the market, the occasional bus ride. I didn’t take part in any activities or events.”
During one of the hearings, he attempted to explain why the defendants were retracting parts of the statements they had given during the investigation.
“Did I give you permission to speak?” Judge Vovchenko interrupted.
“No, Your Honor!”
“I don’t want to talk to you! Do not attempt to engage me in a dialogue!” the judge snapped.
“On May 17, at 9 a.m., there was a knock at my door. I opened it, and some people in masks told me I was coming with them. They took several phones and a bag containing documents, then locked the apartment and took me out to a vehicle. They put me inside and wrapped a sweater around my head. They drove me—as I later found out, to a location somewhere near Tavriisk,” Semeniuk recounted regarding his detention.
According to him, the “people in masks” did not limit themselves to a single method of coercion; they “beat [me], used electric shocks, water—they used various methods.”
Four days later, the captives were moved to a facility where Semeniuk “was handcuffed to a wall.” Throughout this time, he was kept blindfolded—“for his own safety.” Two or three days after that, the captives were taken to the “Priboi” recreation center in the village of Henicheska Hirka, where they remained until July 1. Afterward, according to Semeniuk, they were held in the “basement of School No. 2,” where they stayed until 25 November 2024—the date of their official detention.
In November, those involved in the case were taken to see an investigator several times; early in the month, they provided testimony as witnesses, and in the middle of the month, they underwent polygraph examinations. On November 25, they were interrogated as suspects.
“I provided testimony that I had spent six months memorizing—learning exactly what I was supposed to say. On November 25, I was brought here directly from that ‘basement.’ I had no idea whether I would be taken back to a basement, or perhaps to a IVS [temporary detention facility] or a SIZO [pre-trial detention centre]. To avoid any further harm to my person, I gave the testimony that I did,” Semeniuk said in court.
According to him, during the six months the accused were held in these “basements,” “masked individuals would arrive repeatedly and ask various questions.” The captives would provide the answers they knew the interrogators “wanted to hear,” because otherwise, they would be tortured. The investigator conducted the interrogations “based on the testimony that had already been given” previously.
In court, the testimony Semeniuk had provided during the investigation was read aloud; he confirmed only parts of it.
“Look, on 25 November 2024, I was brought before an investigator for the first time in the presence of a lawyer. Before that, I had spent six months in unpleasant places, with unpleasant people in masks. During the interrogations, physical force was used against me,” Semeniuk explained. “Given that I had been brought in on the 25th from a ‘basement’—not from a formal detention center or a temporary holding facility, where I might have expected such things not to happen—I had no idea where I would be taken afterward. If I had deviated even slightly from what we had been forced to memorize over those six months, I could not have guaranteed my own safety or my life. I feared for my life. I feared for my safety—and for the safety of my relatives.”
Judge Vovchenko then asked why, during his interrogation as an accused person on 19 December 2024, Semenyuk did not fully admit his guilt.
“Why, after the alleged torture—being subjected to electric shocks or water-based torture—did you immediately offer a partial confession? If you had truly been tortured, you would have taken the blame for every single crime,” the judge reasoned.
Semeniuk replied that it was on that day that his lawyer had told him, for the first time, that an accused person could contest the legal classification of the charges.
“Why didn’t you tell your lawyer or the investigator that someone had allegedly abused you, tormented you, or forced you to memorise a specific statement?” the judge continued.
“Because I was worried about my family. If I were to refuse and say that people in masks had tormented me, beaten me, and forced me to memorise a statement—I don’t know what the consequences might’ve been…”
“The thing is, your testimony contains details that the officers couldn’t have known otherwise—details that could only have come from your own account.”
“They asked me, ‘Did you pass on information?’ I said, ‘No, I didn’t have any contact with Roy.’ They started beating me. They asked, ‘Did you know that Kozhemiatska was in contact with Roy?’ They kept beating me until I finally said, ‘Yes, I knew!’” Semenyuk said.
“Well, so they were beating the truth out of you, then?” Vovchenko asked, sounding entirely sincere.
At the end of the hearing, he raised the question of whether the statements given by the defendants during the preliminary investigation should be ruled inadmissible as evidence, given their claims of having been tortured.
“If, on the whole, those statements align with your position, then there’s no question of any impermissible investigative methods having been used,” the judge concluded.
Bernatska recounted how, during her very first interrogation, she had warned the investigator that she had actually been detained on May 18—a fact that was never recorded in the official protocol. She was told that “it didn’t matter” and that her lawyer “wouldn’t bring the issue up.”
“Bernatska, do you stand by the testimony you gave regarding the charges? Was it truthful?” the judge asked.
“It was truthful, but it was given under physical duress.”
“Well, that’s how you get the truth out of someone! Understood!”
On 12 November 2026, the Southern District Military Court sentenced Natalia Kozhemiatska to 14 years, Anastasia Bernatska to 13 years and 4 months, Pavlo Peleshuk to 13 years, and Kostiantyn Semeniuk to 14 years in a penal colony.
Just before the verdict was delivered, the court heard testimony from defence attorney Anna Yatsenko, who had been appointed to represent Bernatska in November 2024. She recalled that during their first meeting, Anastasia “was completely crushed—she was in a state of shock, asking, ‘I don’t understand—what is this for? How did this happen?’”
The defendants declined to make a final statement, though Bernatska briefly remarked that she had always been, and intended to remain, a citizen of her country. Kozhemiatska began to weep quietly when her defense attorney, during closing arguments, mentioned her son and her late mother.
According to his sister, Peleshuk spends his time in the pre-trial detention centre “reading a great many books” and struggling against the “melancholy and nostalgia” that “sometimes wash over him.” Bernatska writes that, while in custody, she has “learned to play dominoes, backgammon, and a bit of chess,” and has “re-evaluated many things, changing her perspective on herself, her loved ones, and the people around her.”
With Elena Dymova
Editor: Dmitry Tkachev
We are in a difficult position: we still haven’t recovered our pre-war funding levels. Our goal right now is to reach 7,500 subscriptions from international supporters. Only you, our readers, can save Mediazona
Donate now